Heather Baker - Women's Basketball (1998-2000)
 

Heather was the first Lindsey Wilson College basketball player, men's or women's, to be named NAIA first-team All-American. She led the Blue Raiders in scoring in each of her two seasons at Lindsey Wilson and ended her career with a 23.6 points per game average, number one on the program's all-time list. Heahter was named NAIA first-team All-American, second-team All-American, NAIA Mid-South Region Player of the Year and twice earned first-team All-Kentucky Intercollegiate Athletic Conference during her playing career.

Tim Johnson - Cycling (1997-1998)
 

Tim is the first Lindsey Wilson College cyclist to be named National Collegiate Cycling Association All-American. He earned All-American honors in the disciplines of cyclo-cross and mountain biking during the 1997 season helping lead the Blue Raiders to the Midwest Region and Conference championships and a fourth-place finish at the Mountain Biking Nationals. Tim has earned four United States national cyclo-cross championships in his career including the 2000 Elite National Cyclo-cross Championship, the most prestigious cyclo-cross race in the United States. In 1999, Tim won the bronze medal at the World Cyclo-cross Championships, becoming the only American in the cyclo-cross history to win any medal at the World Championships.